Last on MOTD: Roy Hodgson, architecture and morality

IT’S hard not to warm to Roy Hodgson. Well, unless you’re a Liverpool fan, for whom the very mention of his name conjures up images of home defeats against Blackpool and Wolves which, among a large gathering of like-minded souls, may create enough collective rage to blow a hole in the ozone layer above Albert Dock.

(And on the subject of Albert Dock, will whoever is in charge of planning for that area stop allowing new buildings to be thrown up round there? Last time I visited, there was some horrible angular glass and concrete thing springing up beside the Three Graces buildings, and it looked completely out of place. And the waterfront has become cluttered enough over the last few years with the building of the Echo Arena and the BT Convention Centre. The area is an architectural tragedy waiting to happen.)

I can understand why it didn’t work out for Hodgson at Anfield. The Liverpool fans, after all, expected his team to cross the halfway line a little more often. But he’s restored his reputation at West Brom now, and I’m pleased that he has.

For all his experience coaching abroad, Hodgson seems to me as reassuringly English as cream teas, late trains, whimsical indie bands, Sunday league cricket and supermarket self-service scanning machines that insist there’s an unexpected item in the bagging area when there clearly isn’t. (I have no idea, but I like to think he is an enthusiast when it comes to all of those things. I would certainly be very disappointed if he didn’t own at least two Half Man Half Biscuit albums.)

I like the fact that, tucked inside a smart coaching brain, there’s a wry sense of humour. When he secured West Brom’s Premier League survival with a win over Aston Villa a couple of weeks ago, he was asked if he was pleased to hear a set of supporters chanting his name again after his Liverpool nightmare. “They used to chant my name at Liverpool,” he smiled ruefully. I like the fact that he treats triumph and disaster the same, just as Kipling told him to.

And I like the dignified way he conducts himself. There is, I think, a strong moral compass there. He didn’t go wild with his celebrations when he guided West Brom to victory over Liverpool at the start of last month, when he might have felt entitled to. Instead, there was an understated clenching of the fist, and then an embrace on the touchline for Dirk Kuyt, the nearest opposing player to him.

I’ve spent a lot of time writing about Hodgson since 2007. And that’s almost entirely down to the Gubbometer. It’s four years since I started keeping track of which games were last on Match of the Day. (Four years! I could have written a couple of novels, or completed a Master’s degree, or at least made some kind of effort to get my shambolic life into some kind of order. But no. I chose to faff about writing tangential ramblings about the game that’s last on MOTD each week.)

In those four years, Hodgson has popped up last on Match of the Day more often than any other manager – a grand total of 18 times before this weekend. Look, here’s how the league table stood on Friday night:

Only Steve Bruce and Tony Pulis can touch Hodgson when it comes to being last on MOTD. (Bruce’s record is pretty impressive, actually, as he has appeared last with three different clubs in the last four years – Birmingham, Wigan and Sunderland – a record matched only by Mark Hughes and Avram Grant.)

But Hodgson’s record of 18 appearances did come with a caveat. Because the first time he appeared on the Gubbometer, in December 2007, he technically wasn’t Fulham’s manager. He was there in the stand as they drew 1-1 at Birmingham, ready to take charge the following Monday, but Ray Lewington was still the caretaker-boss following the departure of Lawrie Sanchez. Oh Christ, I’m boring myself with this now.

Anyway, I ended up writing about Hodgson’s impending appointment as Fulham manager that week, and how a lot of people thought he was an odd choice, even though he had apparently been a serious contender for the England job that had just gone to Fabio Capello. Or, as I put it at the time: “Roy Hodgson is named as the new manager of Fulham, and just about everyone with a passing interest in English football reacts as if they’ve just been told that Nick Clegg is the new Prime Minister.”

Yeah, like Clegg would ever get into government. Oh.

Hodgson is now the indisputable leader of the managerial Gubbometer, you’ll be glad to know. That West Brom’s match was on last this weekend was little surprise – certainly not to Match of the Day’s commentator.

MOTD’s final match: West Brom 1 Everton 0
Commentator: John Roder

A nice touch on the BBC Sport website – their Premier League match previews have started including a few thoughts from the MOTD commentator who will be assigned to cover it. John Roder began his preview as follows:

“There are only four Premier League matches this Saturday – and you don’t have to be a genius to work out that the other three all have something to do with the title or relegation. So don’t be surprised if this is the last game on Match of the Day on Saturday night!”

It was.

But there was still a surprise, as West Brom kept a clean sheet for the first time since the Renaissance period. (It’s not exactly clear when this last shut-out was, but a recently-discovered Leonardo Da Vinci painting, entitled Fiorentina Founder on the Albion Banks Of Four, would appear to date it around 1498.)

It meant that Youssouf Mulumbu’s early goal was enough to beat an Everton side reduced to 10 men by Diniyar Bilyaletdinov’s second-half sending off.

And in the meantime, Hodgson has gained an extra point on the managerial Gubbometer. Here’s how it stands now:

Hodgson, who guided Fulham to the Gubbometer title in 2009 (and also to seventh in the Premier League, but that’s a side issue), arrived too late to steer Albion into contention this time around. It’s between his former club and Wigan for that honour, which will be decided next Sunday. But I wouldn’t rule out West Brom being last on MOTD most often next season. Then BRMB’s Last on MOTD billboard might actually start to have a ring of truth about it.


1. Fulham: 10 (2L: 6, 3L: 1)
2. Wigan: 10 (2L: 3, 3L: 2)
3. West Brom: 7 (2L: 7, 3L: 1)
4. Stoke: 6 (2L: 6, 3L: 9)
5. Bolton: 6 (2L: 2, 3L: 6)
6. Everton: 5 (2L: 8, 3L: 4)
7. Blackburn: 4 (2L: 5, 3L: 8)
8. Birmingham: 4 (2L: 3, 3L: 7)
9. Newcastle: 4 (2L: 2, 3L: 4)
10. Sunderland: 3 (2L: 8, 3L: 2)
11. West Ham: 3 (2L: 3, 3L: 4)
12=. Aston Villa: 3 (2L: 3, 3L: 3)
12=. Wolves: 3 (2L: 3, 3L: 3)
14. Tottenham: 2 (2L: 5, 3L: 4)
15. Chelsea: 2 (2L: 3, 3L: 1)
16. Blackpool: 1 (2L: 4, 3L: 5)
17. Manchester City: 1 (2L: 3, 3L: 2)
18=. Arsenal: 0 (2L: 0, 3L: 2)
18=. Liverpool: 0 (2L: 0, 3L: 2)
18=. Manchester United: 0 (2L: 0, 3L: 2)

2L=On second last (Sunderland 1 Wolves 3)
3L=On third last (Blackpool 4 Bolton 3)

(Teams are awarded one point every time they appear last on Match of the Day. Teams level on points are separated by the number of times they are on second last, then by the number of times they are on third last. Teams still level at the end of the season will be separated by the drawing of lots at a glittering ceremony in Azerbaijan, hosted by Sepp Blatter, Graham Norton, Tony Gubba, Ken Bruce and/or Rob Brydon, with music from Jedward.)


7 Responses to Last on MOTD: Roy Hodgson, architecture and morality

  1. nick jones says:

    I must admit that the media treatment of Roy Hodgson is nothing short of disgraceful.
    When I say disgraceful I mean disgraceful in the sense that he has received very little criticism for his performance as liverpool manager. Of course when it came to his Liverpool failings it was all due to Rafa Benitez and the Liverpool fans. Rafa Benitez because he supposedly left him with a really poor squad and the Liverpool fans because they wanted Kenny Dalglish as manager and they never really supported him.
    The fact is the fans would have taken to him if he had 1) tried to play positive attacking football 2) been more supportive of the fans and 3) hadn’t bought rubbish players such as Poulsen, Kochensky and Jones. I will even give him the benefit of the doubt on Cole and Jovanovich
    All we got was terrible tactics and a total negative approach which culminated in he worst beginning of the season since Liverpool got relegated. Of course, the media blamed Rafa Benitez, a two times La Liga winning coach, a UEFA cup winning coach a Champions League winning coach and FA cup winning coach.
    I believe like the majority of the media pundits and EPL managers he is a Manchester United Fan (Big no no if you love Liverpool or big yes yes if you are dealing with the media) and consequently criticised the players.
    Of course Kenny Dalglish replaces him and now the team are playing like Barcelona with the same players almost, apart from the garbage which Roy signed and Roy is still viewed as some sort of expert exacerpated because of the fact that West Bromage Albion have had a decent run and stayed up.
    All I can say is I think this is all because of the medias Manchester United bias. I would love it if he ever replaces Alex Ferguson when he retires.

  2. nick jones says:

    I believe in what I have posted

  3. nick jones says:

    Hodgson is hopeless. The worst Livepool manager since the war, maybe ever

  4. mikewhalley says:

    He was the wrong manager for Liverpool, Nick, without question. He didn’t seem to understand the ethos of the club at all. Had Liverpool appointed Kenny Dalglish last July, I think they would have qualified for next season’s Champions League.

    I know Liverpool fans who almost start foaming at the mouth if they hear mention of Hodgson’s name, but I don’t think he’s a bad manager. He’s proved at Fulham and at West Brom that he can turn a team of Premier League strugglers into a respectable mid-table side. That’s a skill in itself.

    Unfortunately, he turned Liverpool into a mid-table side too. The loss of Mascherano hindered him a great deal, but I completely agree with you that he made some awful signings as well.

    And he did get criticism from the media for that – rightly.

  5. HH says:

    Whilst being over the moon happy Kenny is our manager, I think nick and most other internet liverpool fans need a reality check. Hodgson was a temp manager brought in to manager the last mans team for a short period until the club was sold, he was the terrible twins man and therefore had absolutely no hope of getting any benefit of doubt or any real support from us.

    The improvement in the team/squad is undeniable since Dalglish took over, the use of the youth, our youth, Kelly Spearing Flanagan Robinson, the youth who Benitez had denied even exsisted has been a joy.

    Dalglish has also had the benefit of a Suarez and the massive bonus of not having to deal with a sulking unhappy out of form non scoring Torres.

    As too his signings, Kochensky and Jones wasn’t a problem, Poulsen absolutely but it’s strange that Dalglish has kept him in his first team squad and as much as Pulsen has been poor, another of Hodgsons signings made the difference for Dalglish at the start with 5 goals in 5 games, 2 to secure draws and 1 to secure a win v Cheslea.

    And one other thing, it could be argued the Suarez had been targeted by Hodgson as far back as November and if he did have anything to do with his signing then a big thank you Mr Hodgson.

    In the week when Manu has finally knocked us off our perch and we can no longer point to the past and say we are top, nor should we be looking in the past and moaning about what if’s, under Dalglish we have a new manager and we have new owners who seem to be pulling in the same direction. It’s time to stop dwelling on the past and look forward to a brighter future.

  6. Bad Andy says:

    Hang on. The media’s Manchester United bias stopped Roy Hodgson, the then Liverpool manager, getting criticised?
    Nick – you definitely need a reality check. HH has made the most cogent comment by a Liverpool fan I have seen in a long time.
    On the flip side, have Fulham more or less won their trophy back? I can’t see Wigan’s relegation battle will see the Latics last on MOTD next week.

  7. mikewhalley says:

    Think Fulham have it in the bag, Andy! All thanks to Charles N’Zogbia. (Very glad about that, purely because I’m planning a blog post for next Sunday night/Monday morning that relies hugely on Fulham finishing top. All will be revealed…)

    Did wonder for a bit if I should have included tonight’s MOTD2 on the chart, on the basis that there were more Premier League games on Sunday than Saturday this weekend.

    But I didn’t the last time that happened, so I decided not to this time either. After all, it’s Last on MOTD, not Last on MOTD2.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: