Goodbye, Respect

WHAT’S that disappearing over the horizon faster than a coward in a Western? Ah, that’ll be the Respect initiative.

And to think that all it took was a red card for one of the Big Four.

Chelsea captain John Terry’s sending off for rugby-tackling Manchester City striker Jo at Eastlands on Saturday fell into the “harsh, but not outrageous” category. And given that the appeals process is there, I can understand why Chelsea decided to use it.

What has followed since falls into the “weird, if not downright ludicrous” category. Chelsea’s appeal appears to have been based on the suggestion that Terry was not the last man when he hauled Jo to the floor. Terry was not the last man, but that doesn’t matter. A player is sent off for a professional foul if he denies an opponent a clear goalscoring opportunity illegally.

Did Jo have a clear scoring chance at the moment he was fouled? Probably not – he was only about five yards inside Chelsea’s half at the time.

So the terms of the appeal weren’t terribly clear. But then referee Mark Halsey muddied the waters even further by confirming to the FA that he hadn’t sent Terry off for a professional foul anyway. He had sent the Chelsea captain off for serious foul play. The implication of that is that Terry would have been red carded for that foul if he had committed it anywhere on the pitch.

On that basis, the FA were left with little option but to overturn the decision – although it does rather leave the sense that Terry has escaped suspension on a technicality.

But if Terry was wronged, it seems that means the referee must be punished. So rather than take charge of a glamorous Premier League match this weekend, Halsey will now be forced to miss his Sunday lunch to referee the League Two almost-derby between Chester and Shrewsbury. (Where, even if he gives the best performance of his career, he will get a whole load more criticism from both sides for: a) Acting like a big-time Charlie, b) Failing to make any allowances for the fact that League Two players are more physical than those fancy dans in the Premier League, and c) Failing to make any allowances for the fact that it’s an almost-derby.)

There is a part of me that would like to see such punishments meted out to Premier League players for red-card offences. So, the next time a Chelsea player gets sent off, rather than suspend him, instead force him to miss a Champions League game to turn out for Brentford against Exeter.

It’ll never happen, though. Instead, we’ll just get the arguments, and the appeals, and the abuse.

Ah yes, the abuse. That has come from Sir Alex Ferguson, incandescent that Terry has now been cleared to play for Chelsea against Manchester United this Sunday.

Ferguson, speaking at a press conference yesterday, pretty much accused referees’ boss Keith Hackett of bias.

“My information is that Hackett told Halsey to rescind the red card and he would not do it,” Ferguson said.

“If it had been a Manchester United player, Hackett would never have done this for us.”

We’re barely a month into the season, and already the FA’s sweeping Respect initiative, along with the Premier League’s ‘Get On With The Game’ campaign, are on very shaky ground.

But did anyone ever think it would really work anyway?


2 Responses to Goodbye, Respect

  1. Andrew Boyers says:

    Do you think the problem would benefit from referees being more accountable for their actions?

    The current protocol of relegating referees for a week or two on the back of a bad decision won’t improve anything – what is it meant to achieve? It’s like sitting them in a corner and saying ‘Think about what you’ve done!’ Not really beneficial.

    However, I think if referees gave a brief interview after a match – which would obviously be particularly relevant if he had made a bad decision – would go some way to improving relations between referees, players, managers and fans. It would give them closure, in some respect – at least they would have an explanation, rather than speculating angrily as is currently the norm.

    If a referee is willing to stand up and be counted after he’s made a decision, I know I certainly would have far more respect for him immediately. Rob Styles has done just that and I commend him for it.

    Honestly – what’s the worst that could happen?

    Great blog here – very entertaining and your experience shines through!

  2. mikewhalley says:

    I remember Paul Durkin – who I thought was an outstanding referee – admitting on TV after a Man United v Newcastle game in 2004 that he had been wrong not to give Alan Shearer a penalty when he had clearly been brought down by Tim Howard.

    Durkin, like Styles, won a lot of respect for doing that.

    It’s a very interesting point you raise. I wonder if, at some point over the next couple of years, the Professional Game Match Officials Board might consider making referees available for post-match press conferences as a matter of course, just as managers are now.

    Thanks for the kind comments about the blog.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: